Failure Post: Why My "20 Questions About Australia" Blog Post Failed (And What I Learned)

As an SEO consultant, I spend my days analyzing what works. But today, I want to be completely transparent and talk about something that didn't work.

As an SEO consultant, one of my favourite things to do is keyword research. So, a few weeks ago, I had a fun idea: I'd look up the most random questions people ask Google about Australia and turn it into a blog post.

I wrote the article, "Your Top 20 Questions About Australia, Answered!" I published it, and after a few days, I saw that it was successfully indexed by Google. And then... crickets. Twenty days later, it was still getting virtually no impressions and no clicks.

So, what happened? Why did a well-written, well-researched, and properly indexed article completely fail to get any traffic? I decided to do what I do for my clients: I took a step back and diagnosed the problem.

The Short Answer:

 My post failed because I broke one of my own cardinal rules: I strayed too far from my core expertise. I tried to compete in a broad, general-knowledge category against global giants, and my lack of established topical authority on "Australian trivia" meant Google simply wasn't interested.

My Investigation: Diagnosing the Failure

My process for figuring this out was simple. First, I looked at my own Google Search Console data, which confirmed the page was indexed but wasn't being shown for any valuable queries. Second, to get an unbiased opinion, I had a "conversation" with my AI assistant, Gemini, for a strategic analysis. The combination of my own data and the AI's pattern recognition led me to three clear, unavoidable conclusions.

Learning #1: Topical Authority is Everything

This was the biggest lesson. Google sees my website as an authority on SEO, digital marketing, and resources for creators. This new article was on a completely different topic. I had wandered out of my lane of expertise, and Google noticed.

Learning #2: You Can't Compete with Giants on Their Turf

For the broad questions I was trying to answer ("What is the capital of Australia?"), I was competing with Wikipedia, National Geographic, and official government tourism websites. It is almost impossible for a small business blog to outrank these global authorities on a general knowledge topic.

Learning #3: SEO Still Requires Patience

While 20 days is enough to see if a post is being ignored, it's not enough time to judge its full potential. Even a perfectly optimized post on a topic you're an expert in can take 3-6 months to gain real traction.

A Checklist to Manage Your Own Expectations

To avoid making the same mistake I did, here is a simple checklist of questions every blogger should ask themselves before hitting publish.

• Do I have real authority on this topic? Does this topic fall within your core area of expertise? If not, you will be fighting an uphill battle to convince Google you are a trustworthy source.
• Did I pick a main keyword for the title? Is your title clear and focused? Does it target a specific question or phrase that your ideal reader is searching for? A vague title will get lost in the noise.
• Can I link this to other content on my site? Does this new post fit into a larger content cluster? If you can't naturally link to it from your other posts and pages, it might be an "orphan topic" that doesn't align with your overall strategy.

A Lesson in Humility and Strategy

Am I disappointed that my fun article failed to bring in new traffic? Not really. And I am not going to delete it. It is still a nice piece of content for my actual, existing readers, and it was a joy to write. Plus, if I ever decide to build a larger content cluster around my "French-Aussie Mum Life," it will be the perfect foundation.

This experience was a fantastic real-world case study in the principles I advise my clients on every single day. It's a lesson that being a "real human" means you're always learning, and that even experts can make strategic missteps. The key is to be honest about them, learn from them, and stay focused on your core mission: providing real, tangible value where you are a true expert.

Feeling overwhelmed by your store's SEO?

If you're struggling with indexing issues, keyword cannibalization, or just don't know where to start, I can help. My freelance SEO services are designed to give you a clear, actionable plan to grow your online store.